Wiltshire Police and Crime Commissioner Philip Wilkinson has joined 30 fellow Police and Crime Commissioners, Police Fire and Crime Commissioners and Deputy Mayors in writing to the Prime Minister calling on the Government to rule out any top-down programme of police force mergers.
The joint letter, signed by 31 policing leaders from across England, warns that replacing local police forces with a small number of large regional organisations would weaken local accountability, contradict the Government's devolution agenda and risk years of costly disruption without clear evidence of improved outcomes for the public.
The intervention follows continuing debate over the future structure of policing in England and Wales, including recent calls for a reduction in the number of police forces nationally – and follows Mr Wilkinson’s response on ‘mega forces’ last week.
Mr Wilkinson said: "I have already made clear my concerns about proposals to replace local police forces with large regional organisations, but it is significant that PCCs and policing governance leaders from across the country have now come together to express those concerns directly to the Prime Minister.
"The issue is not whether policing needs reform. It does. The issue is whether abolishing local police forces is the answer.
"The evidence simply does not support the argument that bigger automatically means better. Some of the strongest performing forces in the country are smaller forces, and there is no clear evidence that replacing local forces with regional organisations would improve outcomes for communities.
"What concerns me most is that this debate has become focused on organisational structures rather than on the things that really matter to the public: visible neighbourhood policing, tackling crime, supporting victims, improving performance and strengthening public confidence.
"There is also a wider question of accountability. At a time when Government is rightly talking about devolving power away from Whitehall and bringing decision-making closer to communities,
it seems contradictory to consider policing structures that would move decisions further away from the people they affect.
"Local policing works best when local people have a strong voice in the priorities being set and can clearly see who is accountable for the service they receive.
"Reform should be evidence-led, focused on improving policing outcomes and driven by the interests of the public, not by assumptions that creating larger organisations will somehow solve challenges that are often about leadership, culture, performance and accountability.
"Before embarking on the biggest restructuring of policing in a generation, Government must clearly demonstrate how it would improve public safety, strengthen accountability and deliver better value for taxpayers. At the moment, I do not believe that case has been made."

Salisbury Cathedral contributes more than £21 million to the economic life of the city each year, says new report
Salisbury FC Reveal FA Cup Ticket Details for Blackpool Clash
Leading theatre figures back £22m Salisbury Playhouse transformation as campaign launches in Westminster
Enter the Stars Appeal Christmas Raffle for the chance to win £2,000
Salisbury breeze past Chichester City to reach third round of FA Trophy
Salisbury community to come together in memory of loved ones at annual Light Up a Life celebration
Salisbury man found guilty of raping woman in Prague
Woman dies following collision in Amesbury
